Born and raised in McComb, Beth is a 1983 McComb High School graduate, and she is also a graduate of Bowling Green State University. She is married to Craig Fenstermaker and has two sons and two stepdaughters. She has worked for Grubb Construction and Northwest Ohio Crane Service for the past twenty-two years managing day to day operations. 

Beth is also involved in the McComb Lions Club and is currently on the Leo Club Committee and Scholarship Committee.

In her spare time, she likes to travel to new places in the US, go camping and boating at Lake Erie, spend time gardening and spoiling her two black cats.